City of Surveillance? The Implications of Sidewalk Labs’ Resolution to Build a Smart City in Toronto
thesisposted on 22.05.2021, 17:41 by PATIL DADAYAN
ABSTRACT Google’s sister company Sidewalk Labs has proposed to build a smart city on the Eastern end of Toronto’s waterfront. This initiative is the first of its scale in North America. With the creation of a smart city come implications for the technological, political and cultural life of a city, that give Sidewalk Labs unprecedented power in the realm of urban governance. This study aims to examine whether or not Sidewalk Labs is offering a city of surveillance. Building on existing work on the influence of data, big tech and governance, as well as the cultural importance of neighborhoods, it aims to explain the possible outcomes of the decision to adopt such an initiative in a multicultural urban environment. Alongside a review of the literature on surveillance capitalism, governance and modern urban theory, discourse analysis of the recent Master Innovation and Development Plan (MIDP) released was conducted. Analysis of the material demonstrated a possible desire to control and lead, with data as the key instrument granting the tech company power of uncompetitive nature. The results indicate that there could be negative implications associated with the creation of a smart city in Toronto, but are not of unruly scale. On this basis, it is recommended that Canada update its privacy protection laws to include technological advancements of this scale, and require government involvement in the project at every stage.
DegreeMaster of Professional Communication
Granting InstitutionRyerson University
LAC Thesis TypeThesis
City planning -- Ontario -- TorontoUrban renewal -- Ontario -- TorontoWaterfronts -- Ontario -- Toronto -- PlanningCities and towns -- Effect of technological innovations onSmart citiesCity planningConsumer profiling -- Data processingInformation technology -- Social aspectsBig data -- Economic aspects